ORIENTAL UNIVERSITETIQidiruvПоискSearch
Oriental universiteti nashriyotiIlmiy jurnallar platformasiПлатформа научных журналовScholarly journals platform

Toʻliq matnПолный текстFull text

“If we can’t master English, it’s a shame”: millennial university students’ identity and investment in acquiring English

Hagung Yudistira Utomo, Christine Manara

Matn PDF dan avtomatik ajratilgan: ekran oʻqiydigan dasturlar, telefon va qidiruv uchun. Rasmiy nusxa — PDF.Текст извлечён из PDF автоматически — для программ чтения с экрана, телефонов и поиска. Официальная версия — PDF.Text was extracted from the PDF automatically for screen readers, phones and search. The PDF remains the version of record.

PDF ni oʻqishЧитать PDFRead the PDF → Nashr kartasiКарточка изданияRecord

“IF WE CANʼT MASTER ENGLISH, ITʼS A SHAME”: MILLENNIAL
UNIVERSITY STUDENTSʼ IDENTITY AND INVESTMENT IN ACQUIRING

ENGLISH

Hagung Yudistira Utomo,
English Literature Department, Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities,

University of Pakuan, Bogor, Indonesia
hagungyudistirautomo@gmail.com

Christine Manara,
Doctoral Program of Applied English Linguistics,

Faculty of Education and Languages,
Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia, Jakarta, Indonesia

https://zenodo.org/records/17339751

Abstract. Academic success, career advancement, and global citizenship require
English. This study examines university studentsʼ views on Englishʼs value and
motivation to learn it. This study also examines academic, professional, personal, and
cultural English learning motivations. Qualitative research used in-depth interviews to
analyse student narratives. Seven Bogor private university millennial English majors
volunteered for interviews. Post-transcription interviews were analysed. Interview
themes were examined using thematic analysis. According to the study, English is
essential for professional, educational, and personal growth in the globalized world.
Study: university students need English proficiency. English multilingualism has
strengthened international identities.

Keywords: Globalization, English as a Lingua Franca, Multilingual identity,
Linguistic capital, Qualitative research.

Introduction. English is a global, universal language that affects academia,
business, technology, and culture (Darvin and Norton, 2018). This influence warrants
studying its effects on university students (Zhang, 2023; Vasilopoulos, 2015). This
interconnected world makes English a powerful lingua franca, facilitating crosscultural interactions, academic exchanges, and international collaborations, according
to Moga (2020). This research examines how university students view English in their
lives and why they choose to learn it. English proficiency has become an essential tool
for academic success, career advancement, and engagement in a globalized society.

Language mastery involves many complex language attitudes rooted in personal,
cultural, and social factors (Norton et al., 2020). English impacts university studentsʼ
emotional, cultural, and practical lives. In an increasingly diverse and intercultural
world, language attitudes can reflect identity, aspirations, and a sense of belonging,
according to Suwartono (2011). Furthermore, understanding why university students
learn English is crucial. These motivations include career goals, academic
requirements, personal interests, and global awareness. These drives can illuminate
language acquisition complexity and higher education language learning dynamics
(Darvin and Norton, 2018; Alshammari, 2018).

Previous studies have shown the importance of English in society, especially for
students. Anggraini et al. (2023) found that many students were motivated to learn
English because of its perceived benefits to academic performance and career
prospects. Mushtaque et al. (2022) examined ESL studentsʼ investment habits. The
findings suggested several ways to understand studentsʼ English habits and help them
achieve their goals. Identifying studentsʼ investment practices, assessing investment
levels, and assessing investment efficacy. Mushtaque et al. (2022) added that these
investment practices significantly impact studentsʼ language proficiency and goal
achievement. Teachers should analyze studentsʼ academic progress using different
investment strategies, identify areas for improvement, and develop investment
strategies to improve studentsʼ investment habits. Finally, studentsʼ investment
practices must be evaluated regularly. These previous studies did not address how
learnersʼ individual motives were informed and/or interacted with ideological forces
outside classrooms. Thus, exploring these intangible forces—past ideology, current
perspectives and attitudes, and aspirations of living in a globalization era—can help
explain how individuals interact with these forces to shape their imagined identity as
English users.

In the light of understanding studentsʼ investment in English language acquisition,
this research addressed two primary research questions: 1) What do university students
think of English in their present and near future lives? and 2) How do these perceptions
and their engagement with English speaking communities inform their drives to
acquire English? This study delved into studentsʼ perspectives, attitudes, and emotional
connections with English across academics, personal life, and cultural contexts. The
questions also explore studentsʼ academic, career, personal, and cultural motivations
for learning English.

The notion of investment and language identity in Second Language
Acquisition

Drawing on Bourdieuʼs (1991) ideas, Darvin and Norton (2018) conceptualize
investment as the link between a learnerʼs motivation and their commitment to learning
a language, both in educational contexts and wider communities. Moga (2020) adds
that this investment is shaped by learnersʼ interactions with peers who use or are
learning the target language. As learners acquire a new language, they continuously
build and negotiate their identities, deciding which roles they wish to adopt in specific
contexts. Darvin and Norton (2018) emphasize that language learning investment
involves setting goals, practicing regularly, and shaping identities through social
relations and power structures. Such investment also entails dedicating time, effort, and
financial resources. Anggrai et al. (2023) note that English learners devote these
resources expecting to gain valuable benefits, though the level of investment depends
on their background, motivation, and environment. Moreover, Darvin and Norton
(2018) stress that language learning is tied to access to economic, cultural, and social
capital, offering learners potential gains in social influence and cultural authority.

However, Norton and Toohey (2011) caution that not all investment stems from
motivation, as factors like discrimination, marginalization, and unequal power
relations can hinder learnersʼ willingness to engage. These barriers can limit access to
learning opportunities. Nonetheless, learners often invest because they believe English

proficiency will bring symbolic benefits (such as education, employment, and social
networks) and material gains (like income and property) (Norton et al., 2020). Norton
also defines identity as individualsʼ evolving understanding of themselves in relation
to the world. Identity shapes learnersʼ motivation, engagement, and performance in
language learning. Positive identities foster confidence, participation, and
improvement, while negative ones may lead to disengagement. Because language
learning and identity are interrelated, educators must use diverse teaching approaches
and help students explore identity positions that support social interaction and learning
(Norton, 2018).

Previous studies on Second language identities
Jaidev (2022) explored the experiences of three Saudi students—Mohamet,
Firdaus, and Ahmet—who participated in an intensive English program in Singapore.
Mohamet had taken additional English courses, Ahmet had previously studied English
in Singapore, while Firdaus had six years of English learning in Saudi Arabia but with
limited speaking practice. According to Darvin and Norton (2018), achieving
proficiency in English requires strong commitment. However, the absence of Arabic
speakers and the need to adapt to unfamiliar social and cultural environments left the
students feeling disoriented (Jaidev, 2022). Darvin and Norton (2018) also emphasize
that identity must be understood within existing social power structures.
Teng (2019) examined how identity, once seen as an individual aspect of learning,
has become central in EFL research. Teng argued that identity is closely tied to
community and shifts as communities change, making it fluid, complex, and sometimes
contradictory. Over the past decade, identity and investment in EFL have gained
attention because learners adopt different social roles. Teng found that learners
prioritize practicality and relevance in their learning investment, but power abuse,
social tensions, and lack of cohesion can weaken their commitment and academic
ethics.
Similarly, Annisa et al. (2023) studied how rural vocational high school (VHS)
students build identity and commitment through English learning. Using interviews
and focus groups with six students, they found varied perceptions, from recognizing
Englishʼs career value to expressing reluctance. Challenges included ineffective
teaching, poor classroom conditions, weak foundational knowledge, limited support,
and part-time work. Teachersʼ encouragement was seen as crucial for sustaining
motivation and improving proficiency.
Lastly, Mushtaque et al. (2022) analyzed ESL studentsʼ learning investments,
urging teachers to use authentic, contextual approaches. They suggested that routine,
real-life-based tasks enhance metacognitive awareness and help students move from
passive knowledge to active language use.
Research methods. This study explored research questions using qualitative
methods. It examined how social capital and identity change affect learnersʼ English
language acquisition across contexts and time. Creswell (2018) defines qualitative
research as studying peopleʼs social comprehensions. Often, narratives are used to
gather data. Qualitative research using narrative inquiry emphasizes collaboration,
extended engagement, and a specific location or group of people. Understanding
peopleʼs narratives, lived experiences, and interpersonal interactions is the goal.

Qualitative research is suitable for this study because it examines studentsʼ
interpretations and sense-making to better understand their social reality.

Seven university students from Bogor, West Java, Indonesia, representing a
semester (1, 3, 5, 7) in the English Literature program participated in the study. The
class had three boys and four girls. The students were chosen because their English
grades were middle to high and they participated actively in class discussions. The
GPA results from each semester were used to draw these conclusions. In this study,
pseudonyms were used to protect participant privacy. To maintain confidentiality, all
participants must sign a letter of informed consent. This study gave participants unique
identifiers for anonymity and clarity. RC, JS, AK, ZY, JP, AW, and YM were the
participants.

In-depth interviews were used to gather comprehensive and distinct explanations
from participants to determine their identities and level of investment in learning
English. To understand participantsʼ responses to a phenomenon, the interview
questions probed their subjective experiences, opinions, motivations, and strategies for
learning English to succeed in college. In-depth interviews were conducted face-toface. The event was scheduled based on participant availability and suitability. The
researchers used Bahasa Indonesia, the national language, during the interviews to help
participants feel comfortable sharing their thoughts.

Thematic analysis was used to analyze In-Depth interview data. Caine (2022)
describes thematic analysis as a series of qualitative data analysis steps. The following
are items: Initial steps include transcribing interview data. Before data translation, the
data was closely read and listened to to establish familiarity and identify recurring
themes in the participantsʼ accounts and extracts that best answered the research
questions.

Findings and discussion. In general, when asked how the students value English
in their daily lives, some salient conceptions were attached to the way they describe
“English”. These are presented using key words like “access to information”,
“communication”, “social media and technology”, “opportunities”, “reconciliation”,
“international relation,” and “connection”. Participants view these values as having
connected to the present globalization era in which thirst of connection across the globe
was heavily felt by these young millennials. The following sub-sections discuss the
details of the participants investment in acquiring English.

English as the language of global participation and self-expansion
The millennial students interviewed expressed a strongly positive view of English,
considering it indispensable in the era of globalization. They recognized English as the
global lingua franca that provides greater opportunities and access in an increasingly
interconnected world. For them, English is not only a communication tool but also a
gateway to wider networks of knowledge, culture, and professional growth.
Growing up in a time of rapid technological advancement, these millennials also
value recognition and visibility on digital platforms, where global interaction has
become part of daily life. Their eagerness to transcend borders—both physically and
virtually—reflects how deeply they associate English proficiency with broader
participation and mobility. They described English as enabling them to connect with

diverse communities, expand their reach, and engage with global conversations that
shape their present realities.

“…since English is a global, international language, it allows me to discover
wider world, as a wider space for me to grow in social [media], sort of more chances
to explore things that we might not find in our nation. So, I think itʼs pretty helpful for
my communication… more than just making friends, but I can also explore more things
outside of [Indonesia]… like technology, studying abroad, and also about other
cultures.” – JS

In my opinion, very important. The reason is because one, English, the number
one international language. And then, almost everything now on social media,
everywhere, uses a lot of English. And by learning English in this era of globalization,
we can connect with people who are not only Indonesian. – AW

The excerpts show that participants value English in the globalized world. They
see it as a global language that allows internet access to diverse cultures, languages,
and resources, symbolizing cross-border opportunities. Many migrants worldwide
need English to communicate, integrate, and work in their adopted countries. It helps
them claim their place in society and improve their prospects. English is the “currency
of global participation,” enabling people to join and thrive in global networks,
according to Wee and Park (2012).

Participants also said learning English improved their participation in
international social media communities, boosting their global citizenship. Their online
presence and confidence in cross-cultural communication improved with English
proficiency. Technology and the internet enhance these opportunities, allowing them
to become global citizens. Their experiences suggest that learning English boosts
global presence, self-confidence, symbolic capital, and diverse thinking.

English acquisition and imagined identity
Millennial students said they value English because many jobs, especially in
multinational companies and international organizations, require it. The students
believed that English proficiency opened up new fields of knowledge and a wealth of
information and opportunities, especially for their future aspirations, as shown in the
following excerpts.
So, Iʼm hoping to get a scholarship to study abroad. After receiving the
scholarship, I will graduate and then live in an English-speaking country to broaden
my experience. For example, the United Kingdom is my ideal destination. That is
something I am very interested in doing. To be an interpreter and, if possible, a lecturer
there. Then I will undoubtedly return to Indonesia as a lecturer. – RC
As seen above, the millennial students indicated that proficiency in English can
provide a competitive advantage in their future professional endeavors (such as a
translator and a lecturer). The reason for learning English is rooted in its fundamental
purpose of facilitating communication. By acquiring this skill, individuals can broaden
their knowledge and pursue their desired career paths in the future. From this
perspective, the acquisition of English affords possibilities of (professional, personal,
and social) identities. These excerpts affirm what Darvin and Norton (2018) indicated
that identity is often understood as the studentʼs subjective understanding of their
relationship with the world, how it is influenced by various factors (in this case the

acquisition of English) and circumstances (such as globalization era), and their
perception of possible future paths.

English as linguistic and cultural capitals in the academic setting
English serves as the predominant medium of instruction in numerous
universities, and possessing a high level of English proficiency grants individual access
to a wide range of international study programs and collaborations. Prompted with
question asking about their experiences where English language skills opened up
opportunities, the millennials pointed out how learning English benefitted them with
academic literacy skills in English as best represented by the following excerpts.
“In enriching the experience after learning English, itʼs better, when we read
English journals that are really needed for semester 7, English books, we understand
much faster even though it doesnʼt always have to be translated first but we already
understand what is meant and what the purpose of the book and journal is. Just for the
thesis.” – AW
Their enrollment to the English Department is a form of investing in the
acquisition of language knowledge (e.g. grammar, phonology, and English varieties)
and skills (speaking, reading, and translation) in the academic setting. Excerpt depicts
how the millenials believed that the acquisition of academic English literacy equipped
them with symbolic linguistic and cultural capitals (i.e., knowledge and language
skills) to operate at their current academic environment as well as to enter professional
community of practice in the near future.
Norton et al. (2020) emphasized that identity strongly influences millennialsʼ
dedication to second language learning. Their motivation to invest in English arises
from how they view its current significance and function. As a dominant global
language, English supports cross-cultural interaction, academic pursuits, and
international collaboration. These students recognized that English proficiency is vital
for achieving success in education, careers, and global engagement. They see English
not as a privilege but as a necessity for accessing worldwide opportunities, forming
new social networks, and joining global events.
The studentsʼ stories show that learning English also helps them acquire social
skills, knowledge, discourse practices, and community involvement. Their growing
commitment increased their use of English-speaking social media, expanding their
cultural influence and social power (Darvin & Norton, 2018).
Conclusion. In conclusion, this study examined how English acquisition
investment, studentsʼ current and future social networks, and identity affordances
relate. Students study English for globalization, career advancement, academic
advancement, and personal development. These four main reasons change their selfimage from English students to English users. As they learn English at university,
students can join more English-speaking social networks. Through these experiences,
they want to be global citizens. Thus, learning English has given them more
opportunities and identities in todayʼs globalized world.
This study also shows that qualitative inquiry can help us understand peopleʼs
social and educational realities. Millenial studentsʼ narrative accounts can provide
meaningful and contextual information on their subjective perceptions and experiences
without generalizing. However, this study has limitations. First, it emphasizes

university studentsʼ English investment. The findings did not capture how they aligned
their efforts with their target community of practices. Future research can examine how
students enter these communities of practices. Second, this study only used in-depth
interviews to gather data on studentsʼ limited academic experiences. Studentsʼ
communicative interactions in virtual English-speaking communities and how they
move between communities can be studied further. Studying their digital
communication practices can help you understand how students project their multiple
selves in English. Future research can examine how language policies, curriculum
design, and support services facilitate or limit studentsʼ English learning commitment.
This may involve evaluating language education methods and suggesting
improvements to help students learn English through real-world communication.

REFERENCES

Alshammari. S. H. (2018). The Relationship Between Language, Identity and

Cultural Differences: A Critical Review. Saudi Arabia: University of Hail.

https://www.iiste.org/Journals/index.php/RHSS/article/view/41275

Anggraini, Y., Eryansyah, E., and Silvhiany, S. (2023). THE FACTORS OF

STUDENTSʼ INVESTMENT IN LEARNING ENGLISH DURING ONLINE

LEARNING AT ONE OF SMPN IN MUSI RAWAS. English Review: Journal of

English Education, 11(1), 47–52. https://doi.org/10.25134/erjee.v11i1.6339

Annisa, N., Mirizon, S., and Silvhiany, S. (2023). Vocational High School

Studentsʼ Identity and Investment in Learning English in a Rural Area. Studies in

English Language and Education, 10(2), 926–941.

https://doi.org/10.24815/siele.v10i2.27167

Bourdieu, P. (1991). Language and symbolic power. Harvard: Harvard University

Press.

Caine, Vera. , C. D. J. , L. S. (2022). Narrative Inquiry: Philosophical Roots.

London. Bloomsbury Publishing Plc.

Creswell. J. W., David. C. W (2022). Research Design Qualitative, Quantitative,

and Mixed Methods Approaches: Sixth Edition. SAGE Publications.

Darvin, R., and Norton, B. (2018). Identity, Investment, and TESOL: TESOL

Encyclopedia of English Language Teaching (pp. 1–7). Wiley.

https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118784235.eelt0802

Guion, L.A., Diehl, C.D., & McDonald, D. (2011).Conducting an in-depth

interview. http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu

Jaidev. R. (2022). Investing in Learning English: A Case of Three Saudi Students

in Singapore. Singapore: National University of Singapore.

https://www.nus.edu.sg/celc/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/25to42-jaidev.pdf

Moga, M. L. (2020). CAREER IDENTITY AND COMMUNITY INVESTMENT

TOOLKIT FOR HIGH SCHOOL LEVEL ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNERS.

Minnesota: Hamline University.

https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/hse_cp/563

Mushtaque, S., Anwar, R. H., and Zaki, S. (2022). Exploring Pakistani ESL

Learnersʼ Investment Practices in learning the English Language. Journal of Education

and Social Sciences, 10(1), 1–16. https://doi.org/10.20547/jess1012210101

Norton, B., and De Costa, P. I. (2018). Research tasks on identity in language
learning and teaching. Language Teaching, 51(1), 90–112.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444817000325

Norton, B., Nicolaides, C., and Mira, C. (2020). Identity and investment in
language education: an interview with Bonny Norton. In Calidoscopio (Vol. 18, Issue
3, pp. 767–775). Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos.
https://doi.org/10.4013/CLD.2020.183.15

Norton, B., and Toohey, K. (2011). Identity, language learning, and social change
in Language Teaching (Vol. 44, Issue 4, pp. 412–446).
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444811000309

Suwartono, T. (2021). The Pandemic A Leap of Faith: Globalization and
University Studentsʼ Motivation towards Learning English in Indonesia. Malang:
Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang.

Teng, M. F. (2019). Learner Identity and Learnersʼ Investment in EFL Learning:
A Multiple Case Study. Hongkong: Hongkong Baptist University.
https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1201791

Vasilopoulos, G. (2015). Language Learner Investment and Identity Negotiation
in the Korean EFL Context. Journal of Language, Identity and Education, 14(2), 61–
79. https://doi.org/10.1080/15348458.2015.1019783

Wee, L., and Park, J.S.Y. (2012). Markets of English: Linguistic capital and
language policy in a globalizing world. New York: Routledge.

Zhang. Y. (2023). The contribution of personal investment theory of motivation
in second language acquisition. Zhengzhou, China: Sias University.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e16681