PROVERB INTERTEXTUALITY AND POWER RELATIONS WITH
REFERENCE TO SLEEP IN TURKISH AND UZBEK CULTURES
https://zenodo.org/records/17732217
Durdona Abdugʻofurova,
Lecturer of The Higher School of Turkology,
Tashkent State University of Oriental Studies
Abstract. The authors consider the intertextuality of Turkish and Uzbek proverbs
of sleep as bearers of cultural memory and instruments for power relations. Applying
a comparative linguistic method, shows how proverbs encode authority, obedience and
resistance, and the spirit of many different cultures in which they circulate. Applying
the paremiological approach and mixed qualitative–quantitative method, this study
demonstrates how proverbs about sleep correspond to broader social change, as well
as acting as a medium for cultural reiteration. At the same time they show both transcultural cognitive processing and culture-specific values, highlighting the role of
proverb in forming collective identities and regulating social affairs over decades.
Keywords: paremiology, intertextuality, sleep imagery, social hierarchy,
cultural transmission.
Annotatsiya. Muallif ushbu maqolada turk va oʻzbek uyqu maqollarining
intertekstualligini madaniy xotira tashuvchisi va hokimiyat munosabatlari vositasi
sifatida tahlilga tortgan. Qiyosiy lingvistik usulni qoʻllash orqali maqollarning
hokimiyat, itoatkorlik va qarshilik koʻrsatish hamda ular tarqalgan koʻplab turli
madaniyatlar ruhini qanday kodlashini koʻrsatadi. Paremiologik yondashuv va aralash
sifat-miqdor usulini qoʻllagan holda, ushbu tadqiqot uyqu haqidagi maqollarning
kengroq ijtimoiy oʻzgarishlarga mos kelishini, shuningdek, madaniy muloqot vositasi
vazifasini bajarishini koʻrsatadi. Shu bilan birga, ular transmadaniy kognitiv qayta
ishlashni ham, madaniyatga xos qadriyatlarni ham koʻrsatib, maqollarning jamoaviy
oʻziga xoslikni shakllantirish va koʻplab yillar davomida ijtimoiy masalalarni tartibga
solishdagi rolini taʼkidlaydi.
Kalit soʻzlar: paremiologiya, intertekstuallik, uyqu tasviri, ijtimoiy iyerarxiya,
madaniy muloqot.
Proverbs, like many linguistic constructs, reflect a societyʼs attitudes, beliefs, and
general perspective of the world and can serve as didactic devices to transmit cultural
values and ideologies regarding interpersonal relationship dynamics and social
hierarchy. This is the subject of study: the subtle ways in which proverbs inscribe and
carry values about power relations, focusing on one particular area where this takes
place – the realm of aphoristic sayings that use sleep imagery in order to communicate
expectations about how power should be distributed and what peopleʼs
powers/responsibilities are within specific cultures. Its focus is on the ways in which
these proverbs power authority, command obedience, and tacitly or explicitly mark
alternatives to resistance in the texture of Turkish and Uzbek life. Very often, these
expressions represent the wisdom of yore and embed morality lessons and cultural
beliefs that have been transmitted over thousands of years in an abbreviated form. In
this sense, paremiology (the study of proverbs) acts as a peculiar “ocular device” in
which we can observe the ambiguous deployment of language, culture, and power that
characterizes discourse. If we probe the metaphorical and literal representation of sleep
in such proverbs, we can reveal assumptions about productivity, social arrangements,
and power relations that underpin these communities. This cross-cultural comparative
work will illustrate the common ground as well as culturally specific subtleties in these
societiesʼ respective use of proverbial wisdom to express social hierarchy.
This comparative inquiry therefore offers an insight into the extent to which we
can rely on these linguistic phenomena as responsible for shaping general attitudes
towards roles and responsibilities in a culture, with particular reference to power
relations. Additionally, I want to explore what these proverbs say about maintaining
social power or lifting up and undermining oppressive structures and how they each
reflect cultural narratives in a contemporary world that changes for the better. The
scholarly discipline that is engaged in researching proverbs, folk wit, and poetic
aphorisms is called paremiology; its subject matter offers a wide field for exploration
of the intricate relationship between language, culture, and human emotions, as such
expressions usually comprise historical traditions of manʼs common past or folk
wisdom that reflects traditional views peculiar to different people. This is reflected
most clearly in the proverbs, which encapsulate core cognitive processes and rules of
how we express shared human values across cultures. Besides, proverbs are images of
lifestyle, traditions, mentality, worldview, and peopleʼs appearance.
In the course of studying the material on this topic, some pioneering scholarship
on paremiological studies will be critically analyzed with special references that deal
with the relationship among proverbs, culture, and power relations in general and
within the Turkic linguistic area in particular. It will identify the literature that there is
a lack of the specific investigation of sleep proverbs as social ranking and individual
agency indicators. This critical review will lay a theoretical basis for interpreting how
verbal phenomena (e.g., proverbs) codify and transport socio-cultural norms, the
process with reference to which such use of language compartmentalizes hegemonic
relationships and normative modes in a community1. In light of this, the present section
will further examine ethnolinguistic approaches to proverbs, as such are seen as one of
the main sources for understanding sociocultural valuations implicit in these small
phrastic utterances2. It will also review research on symbolic language and imagery in
proverbs, which are vital for analyzing the implicit cultural meanings of sleep within
Turkish and Uzbek culture3. The review will also explore cross-cultural research,
1 Lomotey B.A., Csajbok-Twerefou I. A pragmatic and sociolinguistic analysis of proverbs across languages and cultures
// Journal of Pragmatics. 2021. (182). P. 86.
2 Ramlan M.N. Comparative Ethnolinguistics on Metaphorical Interpretations in Japanese Kotowaza and Malay Proverbs
// IZUMI. 2021. № 2 (10). P. 221.
3 Toan L.N. Symbolic Language and Imagery in Formatting, Preserving, and Transmitting Cultural Values through
Vietnamese Proverbs // International Journal of Religion. 2024. № 3 (5). P. 547.
which helps to demonstrate how proverbs are channels for social control whereby
expectations of obedience, production, and resistance are communicated1.
The theoretical basis for the study of phraseological equivalence of proverbs is
developed on the basis of founding scientific research in the theory of phrases, and it
will help to compare Turkish and Uzbek sleep proverbs2. Such basic concepts are
crucial for us to be able to distinguish between the universal cognitive mechanisms
responsible for creativity in proverbs and culture-specific interpretations, which in turn
can distinguish proverbs across languages3. This article will address the
methodological difficulties faced by a scholar in attempting to study proverbs crossculturally, including questions of translation, cultural context, and their subtleties of
meaning that may be lost or altered because of linguistic and cultural boundaries.
Nevertheless, a cautious methodological attitude, including the one proposed by
Mieder, can help to reveal how proverbs mirror deeply rooted cultural values and the
worldview of a society, going beyond language distinctions4. In fact, the complex
nexus of language and culture makes proverbs often implicitly reflect core social
expectations and power relations ascribed by society, even if the meaning is not stated
explicitly5. Phraseological informants in general, and wise sayings or proverbs in
particular, have been acknowledged as interesting subjects for linguistic analysis that
reflect the history of a peopleʼs life, culture, and outlook, customs, and mental habits –
it embodies the national character6. It is this broad view of things that reveals the
proverbs as a valuable source to study collective memory and national identity.
Furthermore, the importance of proverbs as essential components in preserving culture
and passing on basic moral values from one generation to another demonstrates their
role in shaping the collective consciousness of a community or society7. They
contribute not only to the formation of world perception and conservation of way of
life, but also they serve as the embodiment of the culture during their existing holidays8.
In this view, proverbs are compressed representations of cultural knowledge that can
provide information on social orders or intergroup relations9. Thus, it is consistent with
interpretations observing proverbs as “cultural text” expressing a communityʼs
worldview and value systems. This perspective is reinforced by those such as Schwarz-
1 Muxtarova M.F. Cross-Cultural Analysis: Representation of Some Aspects of a Parent-Child Relationship (on the
Examples of English and Uzbek Proverbs) // SHS Web of Conferences. 2021. (100). P. 2008.
2 Torra A.P. Explorando la particularidad de los refranes: un análisis contrastivo entre español y catalán en el ámbito de
la familia y la amistad // FRASEOLEX Revista Internacional de Fraseología y Lexicología. 2023. (2). P. 40.
3 Manakin V. Proverb commonalities in different languages and its application to Asian Pacific communication // Journal
of Asian Pacific Communication. 2015. № 1 (25). P. 97.; Mohammed T.M.Q., Abdullah I.H. Universality and Language
Specificity: Evidence from Arab and English Proverbs // International journal of comparative literature and translation
studies. 2021. № 1 (9). P. 24.
4 Kuchkinov K.K., Kurbanova D.B., Shoinazarova V.K. Linguocultural Peculiarities of English Proverbs and Their Uzbek
Equivalents. // Theoretical & Applied Science. 2020. № 10 (90). P. 38.
5 Ratushnaya E.R., Zhaparkulova N.N., Kazachuk I.G., et al. Linguoculturological Specific Features Of Phraseological
Units And Paremias In Multi-Structural Languages // The European Proceedings of Social & Behavioural Sciences. 2022.
6 Chulanova H.V., Vnuchkova V. English Phraseological Units as Representatives of National and Cultural Specificity //
Fìlologìčnì traktati. 2023. № 2 (15). P. 39.
7 Kuchkinov K.K., Kurbanova D.B., Shoinazarova V.K. Linguocultural Peculiarities of English Proverbs and Their Uzbek
Equivalents. // Theoretical & Applied Science. 2020. № 10 (90). P. 38.
8 Muxtarova M.F. Cross-Cultural Analysis: Representation of Some Aspects of a Parent-Child Relationship (on the
Examples of English and Uzbek Proverbs) // SHS Web of Conferences. 2021. (100). P. 2008.
9 Sarsenbaeva Z.J., Utebaev T.T. Role of Phraseology in Developing Communicative Competence. // EPRA International
Journal of Multidisciplinary Research (IJMR). 2020. P. 47.
Friesel who maintain that paremiology, the study of proverbs, must be in terms of
culture so that proverbs themselves can serve as mirrors wherein cultural metaphors,
schemas, and categories are reflected. For example, proverbs used by one generation
can be quite different than those employed by another within the same culture, thus
transferring complex, abstract ideas that are not always directly expressed in
contemporary conversation1. This continuity of the intergenerational transfer
underscores its sustained utility in transmitting nuanced cultural wisdom2.
On the basis of above, I describe the results of a systemic analysis of Turkish and
Uzbek sleep proverbs by focusing particularly on thematic clusters, lexical patterns,
and semantic schema. These findings will then be critically assessed, followed by a
debate about authority and obedience and resistance as represented in the proverbial
sayings from both cultures. This comparison highlights the way cultural values and
social dynamics are embedded in them, affording insights into their influence on how
people perceive sleep on a societal level. Moreover, the study will consider differences
in proverb structure and thematic focus as expressive of cultural understanding of sleep
hygiene and its societal stakes. Additionally, the analysis will consider the linguistic
and structural features of these proverbs to explore how rhetorical devices and stylistic
features work together to lend their persuasive force and significance within oneʼs
culture3. In particular, a thematic analysis will highlight or reveal underlying patterns
and recurring images from the gathered folklore in order to help better understand their
cultural/historical significance of such figurative speech4.
This will include an analysis of how sleep-related sayings in Turkish and Uzbek
cultures express implicitly or explicitly social hierarchy and individual submission or
rebellion5. The findings are reported on detailed thematic maps and in the form of
lexical frequency analyses indicating how often certain themes within each cultural
context were found as recurrent or related to one another6. This quantitative method,
when read through qualitative hermeneutics, will yield an understanding of the stealth
operation of proverbs as archiving reservoirs for cultural norms – guiding forces in
society regarding authority and behavior – and channels determining the course for
individual life.
This examination has demonstrated, through its variety of methods and its
thoughtfully juxtaposed analyses, how sleep proverbs in Turkish and Uzbek are
condensed repositories not just of cultural knowledge but also of the social norms that
surround authority, obedience, and resistance. The results demonstrate that such
linguistic constructs, beyond their superficial simplicity, index deep-seated socio-
1 Singh R. Niedzwiedzia Przysluga?Bear’s Favor? Hidden Garden behind the Concrete Proverbs: Cognitive-Semantic
Analysis of Proverbs in Persian, Polish and Spanish // English Linguistics Research. 2019. № 1 (8). P. 20.
2 Ismail K.B.K. The Use of Proverbs and Idiomatic Expressions in Chinua Achebe’s ‘No Longer at Ease’ and ‘Arrow of
God’ // Sumerianz Journal of Education Linguistics and Literature. 2021. № 41. P. 10.
3 Ismaili J.K. Problematic Areas in the Translation of Proverbs // Journal of Cultural and Religious Studies. 2018. № 11
(6).
4 Eslit E.R. Resilience of Philippine Folklore: An Enduring Heritage and Legacy for the 21st Century // International
Journal of Education Language and Religion. 2023. № 1 (5). P. 9.
5 Tursunova D.A. The Meaning and Usage of Family Related Quotes in English Language // Current Research Journal of
Philological Sciences. 2022. № 5 (3). P. 16.
6 Baunvig K.F. From Numbers to Narratives: Word Embeddings and Semantic Graphs as Hermeneutic Strategies in
Textual Analysis // Research Portal Denmark. 2025. P. 32.
cultural dynamics in which universal human experiences and culture-specific power
notions are reflected. More specifically, thematic analyses indicate that there are clear
patterns in the way sleep-as-human-experience is used to both support and call into
question hierarchical orders and individual agency within these societies. This
comparative approach also illustrated how these proverbs constitute an interesting tool
for addressing the past and present development of the Greek social model in general
(sources of knowledge between generations on behavior and social roles).
Furthermore, this study shows that proverbs are elements of intangible cultural
heritage and testify to a peopleʼs long-term collective memory and embed the
culture/language specificities from one generation to another. They further contribute
an interesting perspective on the dichotomy in conceptualization strategies between
universal and relative by showing that even within a uniform (cultural) context
variation is found. Further research might investigate the pragmatic uses and functions
of such proverbs and how they are used in discourse to make suggestions, persuade, or
even criticize indirectly to shed light on their use as a means of interpersonal
communication and social control.
References
1. Lomotey B.A., Csajbok-Twerefou I. A pragmatic and sociolinguistic analysis
of proverbs across languages and cultures // Journal of Pragmatics. 2021. (182). P. 86.
2. Ramlan M.N. Comparative Ethnolinguistics on Metaphorical Interpretations in
Japanese Kotowaza and Malay Proverbs // IZUMI. 2021. № 2 (10). P. 221.
3. Toan L.N. Symbolic Language and Imagery in Formatting, Preserving, and
Transmitting Cultural Values through Vietnamese Proverbs // International Journal of
Religion. 2024. № 3 (5). P. 547.
4. Muxtarova M.F. Cross-Cultural Analysis: Representation of Some Aspects of
a Parent-Child Relationship (on the Examples of English and Uzbek Proverbs) // SHS
Web of Conferences. 2021. (100). P. 2008.
5. Torra A.P. Explorando la particularidad de los refranes: un análisis contrastivo
entre español y catalán en el ámbito de la familia y la amistad // FRASEOLEX Revista
Internacional de Fraseología y Lexicología. 2023. (2). P. 40.
6. Manakin V. Proverb commonalities in different languages and its application
to Asian Pacific communication // Journal of Asian Pacific Communication. 2015. №
1 (25). P. 97.
7. Mohammed T.M.Q., Abdullah I.H. Universality and Language Specificity:
Evidence from Arab and English Proverbs // International journal of comparative
literature and translation studies. 2021. № 1 (9). P. 24.
8. Kuchkinov K.K., Kurbanova D.B., Shoinazarova V.K. Linguocultural
Peculiarities of English Proverbs and Their Uzbek Equivalents. // Theoretical &
Applied Science. 2020. № 10 (90). P. 38.
9. Ratushnaya E.R., Zhaparkulova N.N., Kazachuk I.G., et al.
Linguoculturological Specific Features Of Phraseological Units And Paremias In
Multi-Structural Languages // The European Proceedings of Social & Behavioural
Sciences. 2022.
10. Chulanova H.V., Vnuchkova V. English Phraseological Units as
Representatives of National and Cultural Specificity // Fìlologìčnì traktati. 2023. № 2
(15). P. 39.
11. Sarsenbaeva Z.J., Utebaev T.T. Role of Phraseology in Developing
Communicative Competence. // EPRA International Journal of Multidisciplinary
Research (IJMR). 2020. P. 47.
12. Singh R. Niedzwiedzia Przysluga?Bearʼs Favor? Hidden Garden behind the
Concrete Proverbs: Cognitive-Semantic Analysis of Proverbs in Persian, Polish and
Spanish // English Linguistics Research. 2019. № 1 (8). P. 20.
13. Ismail K.B.K. The Use of Proverbs and Idiomatic Expressions in Chinua
Achebeʼs ʼNo Longer at Easeʼ and ʼArrow of Godʼ // Sumerianz Journal of Education
Linguistics and Literature. 2021. № 41. P. 10.
14. Ismaili J.K. Problematic Areas in the Translation of Proverbs // Journal of
Cultural and Religious Studies. 2018. № 11 (6).
15. Eslit E.R. Resilience of Philippine Folklore: An Enduring Heritage and
Legacy for the 21st Century // International Journal of Education Language and
Religion. 2023. № 1 (5). P. 9.
16. Tursunova D.A. The Meaning and Usage of Family Related Quotes in English
Language // Current Research Journal of Philological Sciences. 2022. № 5 (3). P. 16.
17. Baunvig K.F. From Numbers to Narratives: Word Embeddings and Semantic
Graphs as Hermeneutic Strategies in Textual Analysis // Research Portal Denmark.
2025. P. 32.