A HISTORY OF CULTURAL COOPERATION BETWEEN UZBEKISTAN
AND TURKIYE (1991-2019)
O‘ZBEKISTON VA TURKIYA O‘RTASIDAGI MADANIY HAMKORLIK
TARIXI (1991-2019)
ИСТОРИЯ КУЛЬТУРНОГО СОТРУДНИЧЕСТВА УЗБЕКИСТАНА И
ТУРЦИИ (1991-2019 ГГ.)
Sharipov Azamat Shamilevich
Teacher of the Department of History of the Oriental University
Phone: +998 90 189-93-68
tarixiypochta@gmail.com
Annotation. This article highlights the brief history and specific features of
cultural cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in the late 20th and early 21st
centuries. Cultural cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye has not been smooth
for 27 years. The article fills the gap caused by the lack of scientific research on the
issues of Uzbekistan-Turkiye cooperation in the field of culture in recent years. An
attempt was also made to show some possibilities of cooperation in this regard. It was
concluded that the level of cultural cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in
some aspects of the studied period largely depended on the anti-terrorist measures
implemented in Uzbekistan. Nevertheless, we believe that the ethnic-cultural,
religious, and linguistic proximity of the two Turkic countries is objectively
predetermined and will ensure long-term cultural cooperation in the future.
Keywords: Uzbekistan, Turkiye, Turkic people, culture, Islam, education, art,
tourism.
Annotatsiya. Ushbu maqolada XX asr oxiri – XXI asr boshlarida O‘zbekiston va
Turkiya o‘rtasidagi madaniy hamkorlikning qisqacha tarixi va o‘ziga xos xususiyatlari
haqida so‘z boradi. O‘zbekiston va Turkiya o‘rtasidagi madaniy hamkorlik 27 yil
davomida silliq kechmagan. Maqola so‘nggi yillarda madaniyat sohasidagi
O‘zbekiston-Turkiya hamkorligi masalalari yuzasidan ilmiy izlanishlar yo‘qligi bilan
yuzaga kelgan bo‘shliqni to‘ldiradi. Bu boradagi hamkorlikning ayrim imkoniyatlarini
ko‘rsatishga ham harakat qilindi. O‘rganilayotgan davrning ayrim jihatlarida
O‘zbekiston va Turkiya o‘rtasidagi madaniy hamkorlik darajasi ko‘p jihatdan
O‘zbekistonda amalga oshirilgan aksilterror choralariga bog‘liq bo‘lgan degan
xulosaga kelindi. Shunga qaramay, ikki turkiy davlatning etnik-madaniy, diniy va til
yaqinligi obyektiv ravishda oldindan belgilab qo‘yilgani va kelajakdagi uzoq muddatli
madaniy hamkorlikni ta’minlashiga ishonamiz.
Kalit so‘zlar: O‘zbekiston, Turkiya, turkiy xalqlar, madaniyat, islom, ta’lim,
san’at, turizm.
Аннотация. В данной статье освещена краткая история и особенности
культурного сотрудничества Узбекистана и Турции в конце ХХ - начале XXI
веков. Культурное сотрудничество между Узбекистаном и Турцией не было
гладким на протяжении 27 лет. Статья восполняет пробел, вызванный
отсутствием научных исследований по вопросам узбекско-турецкого
сотрудничества в сфере культуры в последние годы. Также была предпринята
попытка показать некоторые возможности сотрудничества в этом плане. Сделан
вывод, что уровень культурного сотрудничества между Узбекистаном и Турцией
в некоторых аспектах изучаемого периода во многом зависел от реализуемых в
Узбекистане антитеррористических мер. Тем не менее, мы считаем, что
этнокультурная, религиозная и языковая близость двух тюркских стран
объективно предопределена и обеспечит долгосрочное культурное
сотрудничество в будущем.
Ключевые слова: Узбекистан, Турция, тюркские народы, культура, ислам,
образование, искусство, туризм.
INTRODUCTION
In the last decades, the critical approach in social sciences has been attaching great
attention to the cultural component of interstate interactions as the factor sufficiently
influencing the general level and perspectives of the interstate partnership. It is within
this trend that the cultural dimension becomes a supposedly more effective part of the
widely used instruments of “soft diplomacy”. This stipulates the necessity of new
investigations into this factor in world politics.
In this sense, the experience of relations between Uzbekistan and Turkiye, kindred
from the point of their history and from the ethnocultural, linguistic, and religious
proximity points of view, is of special importance, especially if we take into account
the active and rather efficient usage by Turkiye of the “soft power” diplomacy
instruments in its Central Asian policy.
Despite this closeness, relations between the states have been developing
ambiguously from the past, from meeting each other with open arms and extending
contacts at the beginning of the independence years to subsequent long-term tension
until present-day activation and the all-round deepening of the Uzbek-Turkish cultural
ties.
In what directions and how were the relations between the two kindred people
developing? What kind of challenges and barriers did bilateral ties come across in
developing fruitful and efficient contacts in the sphere of culture? To what degree did
cultural closeness affect the development of their interstate relations, even in this not-
so-simple context? How much can the factor of cultural closeness determine the
perspective of state relations?
The answer to these questions, as well as defining specifics of contemporary
partnerships and their potential for forecasting future relationships, demand a thorough
analysis of this phenomenon, which is the aim of this article. It is supposed that cultural
cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye has not been smooth during the past 27
years, and at some points it has been connected with the Uzbek government's strategy
regarding Islamic extremism and international terrorism.
The changes in the cultural partnership and problems in bilateral relations have
been examined by problem-chronological, comparative, and strategic methods based
on empirical facts. The paper fills the gap that appeared during the last few years due
to the absence of scientific investigations of the Uzbek-Turkish partnership in the
sphere of culture. Besides, efforts have been made to show some possibilities for
cooperation in this sphere. To achieve the goal, after the introduction, the author
describes the role and significance of culture and religion in bilateral relations, then
analyzes the specifics of the cultural cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in
1991–2001, 2002–2012, and 2013–2019 and draws some conclusions on the subject.
LITERATURE REVIEW
The literature on cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in the cultural
sphere from 1991 to 2019 has been explored by several authors. Yuldasheva (2017)
examines the role of Iran and the United States of America in the geopolitics of Central
Asia, providing insight into the various influences at play in the region. Gumarov and
Valeev (2017) focus on the Turkish Republic’s foreign policy in the field of culture in
the Turkic-speaking countries of the EAEU of Central Asia, highlighting Turkiye’s
efforts to strengthen cultural ties in the region. Kramer (2012) discusses the potential
for Central Asia to become Turkiye’s sphere of influence, pointing to the historical and
cultural connections between the two regions.
Additionally, Bademci (1975) provides a historical perspective on the Turkistan
National Independence Movement and Anvar Pasha’s role in the region during the
early 20th century. Veytsel (2014) explores Turkiye’s influence on the culture and
education of Central Asian countries, shedding light on the various ways in which
Turkiye has contributed to the development of cultural ties in the region. Balcı (2003)
focuses on Fethullah Gülen’s missionary schools in Central Asia and their role in
promoting Turkism and Islam, highlighting the impact of educational initiatives on
cultural exchange in the region.
The various perspectives offered by these authors contribute to a comprehensive
understanding of the cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in the cultural
sphere, offering insights into the historical, geopolitical, and educational aspects of the
relationship between the two countries.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
In this article, we analyze the corresponding changes in cultural cooperation
between Uzbekistan and Turkiye. Partnerships and problems in bilateral relations have
been examined by problem-chronological, comparative, and strategic methods based
on empirical facts.
The analysis demonstrates the place and role of the cultural component in bilateral
relations and the outcomes of the two states activity in this sphere. Bilateral
achievements and failures in the sphere of culture have been objectively assessed.
ANALYSIS AND RESULTS
Turkiye’s status in the region is mostly defined by common historic, cultural,
religious, and linguistic ties with the Central Asian (CA) region. That culture is closely
connected with religious values, norms, and traditions. The CA states and Turkiye
belong to the same Hanafi Sunni branch of Islam. According to 1989 data, 93% of the
Muslim population in Uzbekistan and 77.5% in Turkiye are Hanafi Sunni.11
Moreover, Uzbekistan is the cultural cradle of Turko-Islamic history. Besides, it
is home to the great Islamic theologians, Islamic cultural monuments, and sacred places
like the mausoleums of Imam al-Bukhari, Abu Mansur Moturudi, and Bakhouddin
Nakshbandi. Therefore, up to the present, Turkish leaders call Central Asia “оta
yurtimiz”, which means “Fatherland.”.
Similar language, customs, traditions, values, and ways of life are reinforced by
the choice of secular regimes both in Central Asian states and Turkiye. Not
surprisingly, therefore, Turkiye considers itself an ideal secular democratic model for
the states. Ankara’s geopolitical plans are aimed at the political and economic
integration of Central Asia and the Caucasus under its auspices, which could
potentially promote resolution of internal political problems, strengthening its
geopolitical status and influence on the international arena. Turkiye’s long-term
strategy is oriented towards becoming a major player that ensures the energy security
of European countries through diversifying sources of hydrocarbons. In this respect,
the country is attributing particular significance to uniting the entire Caucasus and
Central Asia into a single energy transportation system, providing access to Europe
through Turkish territory. A unique geographic location could make Turkiye a major
terminal and energy bridge between the East and West. (Yuldasheva G., 2017: 102)
To achieve this, Istanbul is very active in using the main instrument of Turkish
“soft diplomacy” in the region: cultural cooperation, which, considering the
commonality in this sphere with Central Asian people, can create a more favorable
moral climate and a foundation to consolidate its positions in the region.
The Turkish policy with regard to Turkic-speaking Central Asia deals with the
activities of a series of Turkish organizations, most of which are engaged in cultural
11 https://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/religiousfreedom/index.htm#wrapper ISSN 3030-3273
- 123 -
projects to protect and propagate the Turkic culture, art, language, and historical
heritage and to transfer them to the younger generations. (Gumarov F., Valeev R.,
2017: 74) These are the Council on Cooperation with Turkic States (CCTS),
Parliamentary Assembly of Turkic Speaking Countries (TurkPA), The International
Organization of Turkic Culture (TÜRKSOY), Turkish Cooperation and Coordination
Agency (TIKA), Foreign Economic Relations Board of Turkiye (DEIK), the Fund
Council on Fostering under the aegis of the Prime Minister, Yunus Emre Institute,
Turkish Business Council (TBK), World Turkish Business Council (DTIK), Union of
Chambers of Commerce and Commodity Exchanges of Turkiye (TOBB), Turkish Red
Crescent (Turkish: Türk Kızılayı), and various non-governmental organizations,
including with the grant system. Nearly all of them have contributed, through their
activities, to the creation of some kind of common modern Turkish culture.
To better understand the religious-cultural issue in Turkish policy, one should also
take into account the discrepancies in the basic ideological approaches of various
groups in Turkiye that advocate different views on the future of Turkiye. Some of them
are characterized by a more ethnic-nationalistic leaning, while others prefer a more
religious-nationalistic orientation. Hence, there are views that pan-Turkist groups
advocate a new regional political bloc of international significance based on ethnicity,
whereas religious circles, including the Welfare Party, favor the creation of a Turkishled Central Asia and Caucasus in the Islamic world in order to re-establish Turkiye’s
primacy among Muslim nations. (Kramer H., 2012)
In the 1990s, some Turkish groups actively used the Islamic factor in their
cultural-educational cooperation with Uzbekistan, which deteriorated bilateral
relations. In spite of that, cultural cooperation continued as both states were quite
conscious of the need to cooperate within the common Islamic space and, in
investigating the scientific heritage of the famous Islamic scientists and theologians,
fight against any religious extremism and terrorism.
Thus, culture and religious issues are closely interlinked in the relations between
Uzbekistan and Turkiye, with religion influencing more or less the depth and efficiency
of bilateral cultural cooperation.
Bilateral cultural cooperation during the years 1991-1999 (first rapprochement)
was uneven and dependent on the political context of bilateral relations.
Cooperation between Uzbekistan and Turkiye in the cultural field is regulated by
the “Agreement on Cooperation in the Spheres of Culture, Education, Health, Sports,
and Tourism (October 19, 1991), the “Agreement on Cultural Cooperation” (July 22,
1993), the “Letter of Intent on Cooperation Between Uzbek and Turkish Republics in
the Spheres of Culture, Education, and Science in 1992-1993” and “On Cooperation in
the Science and Engineering Spheres” (July 9, 1995). In May 1996, these agreements
were strengthened by signing the bilateral Eternal Friendship and Cooperation Treaty.
Moreover, during the 1992 summer summit of ministers of culture from Turkiye,
Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Azerbaijan, and Northern Cyprus, the sides
discussed the issues of creating a single unified language and cultural space that can
create new cooperation opportunities among them. This process has acquired an
institutional structure through the Nakhichevan Treaty regarding the Establishment of
the Cooperation Council of Turkic Speaking States (Turkic Council), signed on
October 3, 2009. The Secretariat of the Council was established in Istanbul. Both sides
were active enough to develop bilateral cooperation in the cultural field.
In particular, Turkish cultural centers started functioning in 1991 in Bukhara and
in 1992 in Tashkent. Since March 26, 1997, the “Ahiska” Turkish Cultural Center has
been functioning in Bukhara and Samarkand, as well as the Uzbekistan Republic’s
House of Culture in Istanbul, to join some 15 thousand Uzbek diaspora in Turkiye.
To develop further Uzbek and Turkish cultural bonds, the “Oltin Meros” (Golden
Heritage) International Fund and its branches in Ankara, Istanbul, and Izmir have been
operating in Turkiye since 1997. The ideological and cultural influence of Turkiye has
also been fostered through television broadcasting in the region.
Uzbek and Turkic cultural relations have acquired an especially warm character
in the literature and poetry fields. Thus, in the past, famous Jadid poet Cholpon wrote
very beautiful poems in Osmanli and devoted his “Baljuvon” poem to Anvar Pasha,
the former Turkish military advisor, who heroically died participating in the Turkestan
national insurgency movement in 1922 under Eastern Bukhara in Baljuvon province.
“Father” of the Turkestan jadids Makhmoudhoja Behbudi, in his “Sayohat hotiralari”
(Memoirs of the Travel), wrote about old Uzbek and Turkish kinship and his
impressions from traveling in Turkiye with sympathy. (Bademci A., 1975)
In the early years of independence, both countries translated and published the
works of many great Turkish and Uzbek poets and writers in newspapers, journals, and
monographs. For instance, Yunus Emre, Yashar Kamol, Aziz Nesin, Fitrat, Cholpon,
Gafur Gulom, etc. In particular, Turkic specialist in the study of literature, Ahsan Botur
was granted the Uzbekistan State reward named after Alisher Navoi for his translations
of the famous Uzbek literary classics.
Simultaneously, mutual relationships have been developing in the scientific field,
mostly in the form of collaborating at various conferences, symposiums, and
congresses. For instance, in May 1992, TICA assisted in organizing the conference
titled “Caucasus and Central Asia: Three Years of Independence: Past and Future.”
The 1st symposium of the biotechnical, genetic, and immunology scientists from
Eurasian states in October 1995, the 4th Cultural Congress on Turkish history and
culture on November 4–7, 1997, and many others took place during this period.
Special attention was given to the arts. Thus, various cultural parties and concerts
were organized in September 1993 during the Uzbek culture days in Turkiye to
demonstrate Uzbek arts. Turkish musicians and singers regularly participate in the
Sharq Taronalari international musical festivals in Samarkand. Much in this regard is
done by the IC organization, founded in 1993 under the Turkish Ministry of Foreign
Affairs, to assist Turkish-speaking post-Soviet republics in economic, cultural,
educational, and technical spheres. Since 1995, TICA’s main activity has been
educational and cultural issues.
In 1992, Turkiye established a special television channel, Avrasya, that has been
distributed to all Central Asian countries via satellite. The main problem with this
approach has been that, to the present, the program reaches only a small part of the
people in the new republics due to the lack of satellite dishes in many regions. (Kramer
H., 1996)
The most significant steps, due to their potential impact on the long-term Turkish
goals in the region, were undertaken in the sphere of education. Already in 1992, Uzbek
higher educational institutions accepted 103 Turkish students to study in Uzbekistan.
Another important state-promoted cultural initiative in Turkiye is the Student
Exchange Project, initiated in 1992 under the aegis of the Ministry of National
Education and aimed at providing university-level education in Turkiye to students
coming from Central Asia, seen as the cornerstone of the “Turkish Renaissance,” – the
project pursued the long-term goal of creating the future elites of the countries who,
well versed in Turkish culture and language, would then act as a bridge toward Turkiye.
Uzbekistan, being a country with the biggest share of the Turkic population, was
allocated the biggest quota of about 2000 students annually in the 1992–1993 academic
year. (Veytsel R., 2014) By the middle of the 1990s, specialists spoke about the intake
of 10,000 students from the Central Asian republics into Turkish universities.
Besides, Turkiye undertook great efforts to make the new republics change their
official script from Cyrillic to a common Turkish version of the Latin alphabet. In 1993,
Turkish specialists assisted in introducing a test system in the process of admitting
students to Uzbek educational institutions. Faculties to teach Turkish were opened at
the leading Uzbek universities, such as the University of World Economy and
Diplomacy, the Uzbek National University, the Tashkent State Institute of Oriental
Studies, and the Samarkand Institute of Foreign Languages. In 1993–1994, following
the adopted bilateral agreements, 28 Uzbek-Turk lyceums were opened in Uzbekistan.
By the middle of the 1990s, Uzbek-Turkish schools counted 65. (Veytsel R., 2014)
At the same time, Turkish specialists admit that before 1995, the scholarship
exchange process between the two states was not effective. If 148 students had passed
the entrance exams by July 1995, this indicator fell to 100 in 1996. Last estimates in
1998 show 360 Uzbek students studying in Turkiye by that time. (Balcı B., 2003: 151)
In 2000, the Uzbek side revealed the propagation of some religious teachings of
the Islamic movement Nurchi, led by Fethullah Gülen, in the Uzbek-Turkish lyceums.
Tashkent had to close all Uzbek-Turkish educational institutions and recall all Uzbek
students from Turkiye.
In addition to the potential threat of religious radicalism from the territory of
Turkiye, Ankara offered asylum to opposition Erk activists, such as Muhammad Solih,
and its attempts to establish an alliance with Uzbekistan based on pan-Turkic
nationalism contributed to the eventual deterioration of Uzbek-Turkish relations by
1999–2000.
Cultural cooperation during the years 2000–2012 (a period of stagnation) was at
a virtual standstill, connected with the above-mentioned political discrepancies
between the two sides. Besides, the inability of Turkiye to provide financial, economic,
and political assistance to the CA region and its preoccupation with its internal issues
and relationships with Europe also considerably affected the Turkish status in the
region. Main Turkish foreign policy priorities remain oriented toward increasing the
geopolitical status of the country by completing the process of accession to the
European Union and providing its decisive role as a transit and cultural-civilizational
“bridge” between the East and West. (Yuldasheva G., 2008: 61) The last task, and
hence the correspondent Turkish position in the world, cannot be fully achieved
without cooperation with Turkish-speaking CA states. Therefore, instead of frankly
pan-Turkism, ethno-national, and religious propaganda, a more moderate model of
“soft Islam” was propagated in Turkiye as the most acceptable way for the
development of the CA states.
Within this course, since 2002, when the Justice and Development Party (Adalet
ve Kalkınma Partisi, officially AK Parti), won plurality in the legislative elections,
Turkiye has been giving much attention to its cultural diplomacy issues. The
traditionally conservative party now tries to join Islam with the Turkish model and
modernity and to balance Turkish relations with the Islamic world, including CA states.
(Mosaki N., 2007)
However, relations with Uzbekistan remained tense as, after the May 2005 events
in Andijan, Turkiye became one of the signatories to the UN Human Rights Report on
Uzbekistan. Despite that, Turkiye cooperated with Uzbekistan within the Organization
of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). In 2007, the Islamic Educational, Scientific, and
Cultural Organization (ISESCO) under OIC declared Tashkent the “Capital of Islamic
culture”. Since 2007, Turkiye has provided Uzbek citizens with visa-free access to its
territory. Annually, ten thousand Uzbek citizens visit Turkiye for trade, tourism, health
services, and labor migration purposes. Since March 21, 2009, the Turkish State
Television and Radio Broadcaster (TRT) Avaz TV channel has transmitted Uzbek
programs in addition to other Turkic programs to activate cultural contacts between
Turkish-speaking states.
Turkish culture has been gradually increasing its influence in Uzbekistan, mostly
through commercial TV and radio programs transmitting Turkish music, cinema, and
television serials in the country. From its side, the Turkish Embassy in Uzbekistan and
the TICA agency organized a series of visits by prominent Turkish singers and artists.
On the other hand, in 2011, Uzbek TV channels criticized Turkish businessmen
operating in the country for corruption and spreading literature with religious content.
Much of the Turkish TV series was excluded from the Uzbek TV programs. The same
year, in October, the Turkish Parliament included Uzbekistan on the list of “unfriendly
states”.12
Thus, from one side, the religious issue contributed to bilateral rapprochement on
the basis of shared values; from the other, distortions in interpreting Islam in the form
of radical teachings negatively contributed to bilateral cooperation in the cultural field.
During the period of gradual rapprochement and renewal of relations (2013–
2019), we can observe first a gradual rapprochement owing to the cautious and tactful
behavior of Turkiye and the absence of any other negative incidents in bilateral
relations. Secondly, the advent of the new administration in Uzbekistan and its new
regional policy have accelerated this rapprochement and sharply accelerated its speed.
This has positively affected Uzbek-Turkish cultural cooperation.
The signs of warming in relations appeared during the 2014 Sochi Olympics,
when then-Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan made steps toward normalizing
relations by meeting Uzbek President I. Karimov. After this meeting, Turkiye once
again appointed an ambassador to Tashkent. This meeting was followed by a visit to
Uzbekistan by the then-minister for foreign affairs, Ahmet Davutoğlu, in July 2014.
Soon, the ministries of culture of both countries signed several agreements on bilateral
cooperation. In particular, on June 14, 2014, at the 4th summit of the Turkish Council,
a Declaration “Turkish Council – Modern Silk Road” was signed. Within this course,
Days of Uzbek Culture were organized in June 2016 in Ankara.
In this context, on July 16, 2016, a military coup in Turkiye, organized by
Fethullah Gulen, the leader of the “Nurchi” movement, also known as the Fethullah
Terrorist Organization’s (FETO) activity, failed. The same year, the Organization for
Islamic Cooperation declared FETO a “terroristic organization”.
President Erdogan’s cabinet's negative stance towards illegal religious
organizations like “Nurchi”, headed by Gulen, has removed a significant barrier to
more deep cultural cooperation with Uzbekistan. Besides, under the growing Turkish-
Western tension, Middle Eastern problems (Syria, Iraq, etc.) required a search for allies
and economic partners. Therefore, Erdogan has finally reviewed his policy in favor of
Eurasia, where Uzbekistan should become the main link in Turkish relations with
Central Asia.
Within this context, Erdogan’s visit to Uzbekistan took place in November 2016,
which signified the beginning of a new era in bilateral relations. During the first highlevel official visit to Turkiye since 1999 by President Shavkat Mirziyoyev, the Uzbek
leader, on October 25–27, 2017, the sides announced that Uzbekistan will join the
Cooperation Council of Turkic-Speaking States. They also agreed to create a Supreme
Council on the Strategic Partnership between the two countries. In 2018, the leaders of
the states signed 25 agreements, including in the fields of science, education, tourism,
12 https://www.bbc.com/uzbek/uzbekistan/2011/11/111101_latin_turkey_uzbekistan
and the arts. On February 10, the same year, a visa-free regime was introduced for
Turkish citizens in Uzbekistan.
Overall, the changed political context and adopted measures have been playing a
very important role in enhancing the development of cultural and humanitarian
relations between the two countries. Thus, the participation of Turkish artists in the
Samarkand “Sharq Taronalari” international music festival and the free re-transmitting
of the Uzbek official festivities for foreign states by the TRT became traditional. To
prepare and retrain qualified cadres for the national economy, increase the quality and
efficiency of the higher educational institutions, and stimulate their scientific-research
and innovation activity, which is one of the priorities in the development of science
and education in Uzbekistan, thousands of students study now in Turkiye, who have
since January 20, 2018 organized themselves into the “Uzbek Students’ Society in
Turkiye”. The same year, the Center of Uzbek Language and Literature was planned
to open in Turkiye on the initiative of the government of Uzbekistan. The sides also
plan to open the Turkology Scientific and Educational Center and the Turkish Center
under the Tashkent State Alisher Navoiy Uzbek Language and Literature University.
In 2019, Uzbek academicians headed by Prof. Sh. Sirajiddinov signed a series of
agreements in Turkiye on the Turkish Literature Fund, Topkapi Palace Manuscripts
Fund, and Turkish World Research Fund, as well as agreements of cooperation with
some Turkish universities. In its turn, the Tashkent financial institute signed an
agreement of cooperation with Turkish Kastamonu University. As a result, Topkapi
Palace Museum granted more than 170 lithographic miniature works of the Middle
Ages period to the Uzbek museums in 2018. (Doğan C., 2018)
Similar views of both sides on the issues of common Islamic heritage have
contributed to fruitful bilateral cooperation in the field of religious education. In this
sense, it is worth mentioning here that some selected representatives of Uzbek youth
were granted the possibility to participate in Qur’an competitions held in Turkiye. On
June 3, 2018, Bukhara Mir Arab Supreme Religious Madrassah signed a Memorandum
with Turkish Ibn Haldun, Kastamonu, and Istanbul Zaim universities. The TICA
agency has been very helpful in supporting the reconstruction and restoration of sacred
mausoleums and other places of worship.
Another rapidly developing and promising sphere in bilateral relations is tourism.
According to the latest data, 41,299 tourists from Turkiye visited Uzbekistan in 2018.
Being the eighth in the world by the number of its tourists, Turkiye is capable not
only of increasing the economic welfare of Uzbekistan and its experience in the tourism
field but also of introducing Uzbek culture to the world. Turkish citizens show great
interest in holy places. Their tourist trips to make pilgrimages can increase the number
of religious and educational activities in the Uzbek tourism industry, as well as create
possibilities for the organization of international forums designed to bring to the world
community the true humanitarian essence of Islam. Considering all this, a bilateral
agreement has recently been reached to attract a leading Turkish expert to work in the
State Committee on Development of Tourism as a Chairman Advisor. Thus, the
gradual rapprochement started in 2013 turns nowadays into a new era in bilateral
relations that was stipulated mainly by the abolition of the religious discrepancies
between Uzbekistan and Turkiye and the new social priorities in the development of
Uzbekistan.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
It is clear that in any circumstances, the ethnic, linguistic, and religious closeness
of Turkiye with Uzbekistan stimulates their cultural cooperation, which can only be
restricted but not cancelled fully. In this regard, the investigation has once again
certified the influence of culture on interstate relations, specifically if we take into
account that culture is closely related to religion, especially in Islam. Any differences
in religious outlooks and behaviors immediately influence culture.
This was not surprising; therefore, post-soviet secular Uzbekistan traditions and
values cannot be compatible with the radical views of some fundamental Turkish
organizations. Moreover, it challenged Uzbek cultural and national identity and, as
such, was not naturally accepted by the Tashkent secular regime.
Mostly under the obvious and, at times, proposed pressure of challenges and
threats from these Islamic radical organizations Uzbek-Turkish cultural cooperation
has been uneven and limited since the end of the 1990s until 2013. It was still slowly
developing in the spheres of music, literature, and the arts, and partly in the fields of
education and mass media. The period of 2000–2012 was a period of real stagnation,
restricted only to partial cooperation in music, films, and mass media.
The absence of any other Turkish involvement in the religious affairs of
Uzbekistan in the subsequent years, the change in Turkish stand on the Gulen
movement, and the new Uzbek foreign and internal policy have laid the basis for the
present-day activation of bilateral cultural cooperation. Today, in accordance with the
priorities of Uzbekistan, bilateral cooperation is primarily oriented toward the scientific
and educational spheres and tourism. At that point, the importance of religious issues
is reflected in the common partnership on this issue to bring to the world community
the true humanitarian essence of Islam and avoid any future discrepancies in bilateral
relations. As a whole, present Uzbek-Turkish cultural cooperation demonstrates both
the success of the cultural diplomacy of Turkiye and progress in the new Uzbek
strategy in the science, educational, and tourism spheres. It is obvious that further
consolidation of the cultural bonds between Uzbek and Turkish peoples will play a
significant role in the rapprochement of the two strategic regions and positively
influence their social, economic, and political lives.
REFERENCE:
1. International Religious Freedom Report for 2017. Uzbekistan and Turkey. US
Department of State.
https://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/religiousfreedom/index.htm#wrapper
2. Yuldasheva, Guli (2017) The Role of Iran and the United States of America in
Geopolitics of Central Asia. Latvian Institute, 2017.
http://liia.lv/en/publications/the-role-of-iran-and-the-united-states-of-america-ingeopolitics-of-central-asia-619
3. Gumarov, F. & Valeev, R. (2017) The Turkish Republic’s foreign policy in the
field of culture in the Turkic-speaking countries of the EAEU of Central Asia. Kazan
State University of Culture and Arts Herald, № 2. pp.73-76.
4. Kramer, Heinz (2012) Will Central Asia Become Turkey’s Sphere of Influence.
Retrieved from http://www.sam.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/8.-Will-Central-
Asia-become-turkeys-sphere-of-influence.pdf
5. Turkey’s Relations with Central Asian Republics. (2019) Retrieved from
http://www.mfa.gov.tr/turkey_s-relations-with-central-asian-republics.en.mfa
6. Özbekistan uluslararasi altin miras vakfi. (2019) (In Turkish)
www.altinmiras.com/?SyfNmb=1&pt=ANASAYFA
7. Bademci, Ali (1975) Korbaşilar. 1917-1939. Türkistan Milli istiklal Hareketi
ve Enver Paşa. – İstanbul. (In Turkish)
8. Veytsel, R. (2014). Turkey’s influence on the culture and education of Central
Asian Countries. Islam in the modern world. Journal. № 1.
9. Balcı, Bayram (2003) Fethullah Gülen’s Missionary Schools in Central Asia
and their Role in the Spreading of Turkism and Islam // Religion, State & Society. C.
31, No. 2.
10. Yuldasheva, Guli (2008) New Foreign Political Orientations of Turkey and
Central Asian States // Central Asia and Caucasus, Sweden, 2008, No. № 1 (55)
11. Mosaki, N. (2007) Situation after Turkish parliamentary elections. Institute of
Middle East. Retrieved from: http://www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2007/29-07-07a.htm
12. Doğan, Cihan (2018) Türkiye ve Özbekistan eğitim konusunda işbirliği
yapacak! Retrieved from: https://www.benguturk.com/turkiye-ve-ozbekistan-egitimkonusunda-isbirligi-yapacak/ (In Turkish)
FOYDALANILGAN ADABIYOTLAR RO‘YXATI:
1. International Religious Freedom Report for 2017. Uzbekistan and Turkey. US
Department of State.
https://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/religiousfreedom/index.htm#wrapper
2. Yuldasheva, Guli (2017) The Role of Iran and the United States of America in
Geopolitics of Central Asia. Latvian Institute, 2017.
http://liia.lv/en/publications/the-role-of-iran-and-the-united-states-of-america-ingeopolitics-of-central-asia-619
3. Gumarov, F. & Valeev, R. (2017) The Turkish Republic’s foreign policy in the
field of culture in the Turkic-speaking countries of the EAEU of Central Asia. Kazan
State University of Culture and Arts Herald, № 2. pp.73-76.
4. Kramer, Heinz (2012) Will Central Asia Become Turkey’s Sphere of Influence.
Retrieved from http://www.sam.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/8.-Will-Central-
Asia-become-turkeys-sphere-of-influence.pdf
5. Turkey’s Relations with Central Asian Republics. (2019) Retrieved from
http://www.mfa.gov.tr/turkey_s-relations-with-central-asian-republics.en.mfa
6. Özbekistan uluslararasi altin miras vakfi. (2019)
www.altinmiras.com/?SyfNmb=1&pt=ANASAYFA
7. Bademci, Ali (1975) Korbaşilar. 1917-1939. Türkistan Milli istiklal Hareketi
ve Enver Paşa. – İstanbul.
8. Veytsel, R. (2014). Turkey’s influence on the culture and education of Central
Asian Countries. Islam in the modern world. Journal. № 1.
9. Balcı, Bayram (2003) Fethullah Gülen’s Missionary Schools in Central Asia
and their Role in the Spreading of Turkism and Islam // Religion, State & Society. C.
31, No. 2.
10. Yuldasheva, Guli (2008) New Foreign Political Orientations of Turkey and
Central Asian States // Central Asia and Caucasus, Sweden, 2008, No. № 1 (55)
11. Mosaki, N. (2007) Situation after Turkish parliamentary elections. Institute of
Middle East. Retrieved from: http://www.iimes.ru/rus/stat/2007/29-07-07a.htm
12. Doğan, Cihan (2018) Türkiye ve Özbekistan eğitim konusunda işbirliği
yapacak! Retrieved from: https://www.benguturk.com/turkiye-ve-ozbekistan-egitimkonusunda-isbirligi-yapacak/