ORIENTAL UNIVERSITETIQidiruvПоискSearch
Oriental universiteti nashriyotiIlmiy jurnallar platformasiПлатформа научных журналовScholarly journals platform

Toʻliq matnПолный текстFull text

Rules of procedure for recording murabaha transactions of financial organizations

Batirova Nilufar Sherkulovna

Matn PDF dan avtomatik ajratilgan: ekran oʻqiydigan dasturlar, telefon va qidiruv uchun. Rasmiy nusxa — PDF.Текст извлечён из PDF автоматически — для программ чтения с экрана, телефонов и поиска. Официальная версия — PDF.Text was extracted from the PDF automatically for screen readers, phones and search. The PDF remains the version of record.

PDF ni oʻqishЧитать PDFRead the PDF → Nashr kartasiКарточка изданияRecord

RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR RECORDING MURABAHA
TRANSACTIONS OF FINANCIAL ORGANIZATIONS

Batirova Nilufar Sherkulovna
International Islamic Academy of Uzbekistan
Associate Professor of the Department of Islamic Economics and Finance,

pilgrimage tourism, PhD
Tel.: +998 97 706-07-34
e-mail: n.batirova@iiau.uz
ORCID: 0000-0001-7542-0825

Annotation. In this article the equity, profit and loss distribution relationships in
equity-based financing in financial institutions are discussed. The characteristics of
each financial instrument are reflected based on the requirements of Islam and
Islamic economics. In particular, the tool of the murabaha is described, which is one
of the Islamic financial services, and the features of its reflection in accounting.
Advantages and disadvantages of murabaha compared to other financial instruments
are highlighted, as well as described features of this document, rules of procedure.
Analyzed payment methods in the transaction murabaha, the characteristics of each
of them. Based on examples, the types of approaches that a financial institution uses
to account for murabaha financing are shown. Particular attention is paid to the
recognition methods based on the gross ratio and constant profit level, which are the
most common methods, the characteristics of financial statements based on these
methods are highlighted, and a table of fees for each method is presented. Also, the
similarities and differences between the murabaha instrument and the financial
instruments offered by traditional financial institutions are shown. At the end of the
article conclusions are drawn about the advantages of using the tool of a murabaha.

Keywords: Murabaha, Islamic financial institution, proportional method,
revenue recognition method, accounting, documents, finance.

MOLIYA TASHKILOTLARINING MUROBAHA OPERATSIYALARINI
AKS ETTIRISH QOIDALARI

Batirova Nilufar Sherkulovna
Oʻzbekiston xalqaro islom akademiyasi

Islom iqtisodiyoti va moliyasi,
ziyorat turizmi kafedrasi dotsenti, PhD

Tel.: +998 97 706-07-34
e-mail: n.batirova@iiau.uz
ORCID: 0000-0001-7542-0825

Annotatsiya. Ushbu maqolada moliyaviy muassasalarda kapitalga asoslangan
moliyalashtirishning kapital, foyda va zararni taqsimlash nisbatlari birma-bir ko‘rib
chiqilgan. Islom iqtisodiyoti va talablaridan kelib chiqqan holda har bir moliyaviy
instrumentning xususiyatlari aks ettirilgan. Xususan, islom moliyaviy xizmatlardan
biri boʻlgan murobaha instrumenti va uni buxgalteriya hisobida aks ettirishning
oʻziga xos jihatlari hamda murobahaning boshqa moliyaviy instrumentlardan ustun
va kamchiliklari yoritilgan. Shuningdek, ushbu instrumentning oʻziga xos
xususiyatlari, tartib qoidalari bayon etilgan. Murobaha operatsiyasidagi toʻlov
usullari, har birining oʻziga xos jihatlari tahlil qilingan. Murobahani
moliyalashtirishda moliya instituti tomonidan uni hisobga olishda qoʻllaniladigan
yondashuv turlari misollar asosida koʻrsatib berilgan. Bunda eng keng tarqalgan
usullardan boʻlgan yalpi mutanosib va doimiy foyda darajasiga koʻra tan olish
usullariga alohida e’tibor qaratilib, ushbu usullar asosida moliyaviy hisobotda aks
ettirishdagi xususiyatlar yoritib berilgan va har bir usul boʻyicha toʻlovlar jadvali
keltirilgan. Shuningdek, murobaha instrumentining an’anaviy moliyaviy muassasalar
tomonidan taklif etiladigan moliyaviy instrumentlarga oʻxshash va farqli jihatlari aks
ettirilgan. Maqola soʻnggida murobaha instrumentidan foydalanishning afzalliklari
boʻyicha xulosalar keltirilgan.

Kalit soʻzlar: Murobaha, islom moliya instituti, proportsional usul,
daromadlarni tan olish usuli, buxgalteriya hisobi, hujjatlar, moliya.

ПРАВИЛА ПОРЯДКА ОТРАЖЕНИЯ ОПЕРАЦИЙ МУРАБАХА
ФИНАНСОВЫХ ОРГАНИЗАЦИЙ

Батирова Нилуфар Шеркуловна
Международная исламская академия Узбекистана,
Доцент кафедры Исламская экономика и финансы,

паломнического туризма, к.и.н.
Teл.: +998 97 706-07-34

e-mail: n.batirova@iiau.uz
ORCID: 0000-0001-7542-0825

Аннотация. В данной статье расмотрены соотношения распределения
капитала, прибыли и убытков при финансировании на основе капитала в
финансовых учреждениях. Характеристики каждого финансового инструмента
отражены на основе требований ислама и исламской экономики. В частности,
описывается инструмент мурабаха, являющийся одной из исламских
финансовых услуг, и особенности его отражения в бухгалтерском учете.
Выделены преимущества и недостатки муробахи по сравнению с другими
финансовыми инструментами. Также описаны особенности данного документа,

правила процедуры. Анализируются способы оплаты в транзакции муробахи,
особенности каждого из них. На основе примеров показаны виды подходов,
которые использует финансовая организация для учета финансирования
муробахи. Особое внимание уделено методам признания на основе валового
коэффициента и постоянного уровня прибыли, которые являются наиболее
распространенными методами, выделены характеристики финансовой
отчетности на основе этих методов и представлена таблица комиссий по
каждому методу. Также, показаны схожие и различные аспекты инструмента
муробахи по сравнению с финансовыми инструментами, предлагаемыми
традиционными финансовыми институтами. В конце статьи сделаны выводы о
преимуществах использования инструмента мурабаха.

Ключевые слова: Муробаха, исламский финансовый институт,
пропорциональный метод, метод признания доходов, бухгалтерский учет,
документы, финансы.

INTRODUCTION
Islamic accounting can be described as an “accounting process” that presents
information (financial, administrative, managerial) related to the stakeholders of
enterprises and organizations based on the principles of Islamic economics. Islamic
accounting enables the evaluation of business and financial operations of enterprises
in accordance with the established requirements of Islamic economics. All
commercial and trading activities must simultaneously comply with both business
rules and the rules of Islamic economics. Human life involves buying and selling,
business and various types of payments on a daily basis. These activities are
categorized, recorded and summarized using a philosophical filter. The content of
Islamic accounting is clarified through the definition of “traditional” accounting.
Conventional accounting is the process of identifying, recording, classifying,
interpreting and communicating economic information to users of accounting data to
make necessary decisions based on analysis, and in Islamic economics, accounting is
also concerned with providing information as in conventional accounting.
Consequently, Islamic accounting and conventional accounting provide information
about the financial result and condition of businesses and organizations. However,
they may differ in the type of information provided, its measurement, valuation and
accounting, and focus.
Conventional accounting provides users with the ability to make informed
decisions under resource constraints, in order to ensure information efficiency in the
market. The importance of Islamic accounting increases in ensuring that the
principles of Islamic economics are followed in the decision making of accounting
data users such as buying, selling or holding investments in various businesses and

organizations. While conventional accounting is designed to record economic
phenomena and processes that have occurred, Islamic accounting also focuses on
presenting accounting data on socio-economic events.

LITERATURE REVIEW
Islamic finance is based on Shariah principles and exhibits many features that
distinguish it from conventional finance. This affects not only the design of IFIs
(Islamic Financial Institutions) products but also the accounting practices of IFIs.
Changes in accounting and bookkeeping practices came from past civilizations that
adapted to changing social, political and economic needs, conditions and systems.
Historical evidence shows that since 624 A.D. Muslim civilizations adopted a
comprehensive system of accounting, reporting and auditing that used a form of
double-entry bookkeeping. The main purposes for the development of accounting and
bookkeeping in Muslim civilizations were to maintain the public treasury (Bayt almol), private commercial transactions (trade), and to record the payment of the
annual religious endowment (zakat). Islamic economics required people to fulfill
their obligations, be accountable, record debts in writing when contracting between
parties, observe correct measures, and not engage in fraud. In the West, double
accounting has been widespread since the 15th century, which was accompanied by
important political-economic changes in the form of a gradual transition from
feudalism to mercantilism and then to a capitalist economic system (Archer and
Ahmed, 2003). In the 18th century, with the onset of industrialization, the widespread
mobilization of capital emphasized the importance of corporate persons and banking
institutions. Prior to 1929, there were various financial reporting practices in the US.
Subsequently, the first attempts were made to standardize and unify accounting
practices in the US with the publication of financial statements, leading to the
establishment of the financial reporting framework. The development of accounting
practices in the US involved several stages. Capital allocation ratios, profit and loss
ratios are recognized as important characteristics of capital based financing.
According to Klebleyeva (Klebleyeva, 2014), the Romans played a significant role in
the development of accounting. After they recognized accounting as a basic
document from a legal point of view, the importance of registers related to the storage
of primary documents, receipt of inventory increased. Depending on historical
conditions and traditions, accounting plays different roles in different countries
(Gritsishen, 2011). In the Islamic economy, financing is not limited to capital but also
allows financing based on trade or sale (Archer, Karin, Al-Deehan, 1998). The
Islamic accounting model is based on the provisions of the owner theory and the
moral norms of Islamic economics, which determine that all individuals, not the

enterprise, are personally responsible for their actions in any sphere of activity
(Sultanbekov, 2017).

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The research methodology for the article on the rules of procedure for recording
murabaha transactions of financial organizations involves a comprehensive
qualitative approach. This includes an extensive review of existing literature,
regulatory guidelines, and best practices in Islamic finance. Interviews with industry
experts and practitioners will provide insights into current practices and challenges
faced in the recording process. Additionally, case studies of financial organizations
successfully implementing murabaha transactions will be analyzed to identify
effective strategies. Data will be triangulated to ensure credibility and reliability,
ultimately leading to the development of a robust framework for the procedural
documentation of murabaha transactions.

ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION OF THE RESULTS
The forms of financing adopted by IFIs (Islamic Financial Institutions) are based
on contracts that are not very different from those of conventional banking business.
Despite the similarities, there are specific characteristics that distinguish asset-based
financing from interest-based lending. Unlike conventional loans, Islamic finance
transactions are directly related to trade and investment activities. These transactions,
offered by IFIs in the form of products or services, facilitate these types of activities.
In addition, the availability of liquidity appropriate to the Islamic economy, along
with the establishment of efficient systems of settlement and exchange, requires a
clearly established basis for measuring performance. IFIs reflect real economic
performance and also ensure socio-economic justice through wealth creation and
transfer. Given this approach, the transformation or replacement of interest-bearing
lending begins with an examination of non-financial sector activities and related
contracts that can be used as financing contracts (Cebeci, 2014). The accounting and
reporting practices of IFIs have emerged as a result of changing interpretations of
Shariah with respect to different regulatory approaches in Islamic finance, different
banking models, and Islamic financial products and arrangements.
Traditionally, trade contracts have been widely used in non-financial areas. The
use of trading contracts is accepted subject to the principles and requirements of
Islamic economics. These contracts require the existence or use of the underlying
asset to validate the financial transaction in accordance with the requirements and
principles of Islamic economics. For example, to finance the sale or purchase of an
asset, it is important to consider the availability and value of the financed item. The
purchase price also includes the profit of the IFI. Financing the use of the asset’s

services (e.g., rent) by the IFI, requires the asset to be operating efficiently. If the
asset is damaged, revenue generation ceases. The absence of the asset or its use
renders the contract void, which affects the financing of the transaction. This differs
significantly from interest-bearing lending, where the loan granted requires
collateralization by a pledge or other form of security not directly related to the
purpose of the loan and its use. The obligation to pay interest is pre-determined and
guaranteed, regardless of the productive capacity of the asset. In this regard, it is
important for every trade transaction to know the basic characteristics such as price,
payment and delivery terms, which can be classified into several categories.

Based on the principles and requirements of Islamic economics, different
characteristics can be formed for each trade contract. The financing arrangements as
well as the options for pricing features, i.e. those that require full disclosure of costs,
distinguish contracts from those that can be determined on the basis of an agreed
price. In addition to immediate and delayed payments, the payment feature provides a
wide range of options by which such payment can be made in advance. On the other
hand, delivery of goods may be immediate or delayed. Delivery times can also vary
in time (as partial fulfillment). Table 1 shows the specific features of murabaha
contract based on fixed price, rate and payment characteristics. Among these
contracts, the murabaha contract has its own pricing character because it is a trust
agreement (Amanah) requiring value disclosure. The rest of the contracts take the
nature of an agreed market price without the need to disclose the value of the
purchase or services.

Table 1

Types of contracts and features of trading

Type of Price Price Payment Delivery
contract determination Completed Immediate or deferred Immediate
Murabaha Costs + profit

In addition, the risks at each stage of financing vary from contract to contract.
The peculiarity of a murabaha contract is that it requires separate disclosure of cost
and an additional mark-up and full disclosure of all costs. This type of transaction
occurs when two or more parties are involved and requires disclosure of costs and a
pre-agreed mark-up representing a fixed profit. When a financial institution acts as an
intermediary, acting on behalf of the buyer (end customer) to purchase goods,
disclosure of all costs incurred becomes necessary (Kudryashov, 2015). The role of
the intermediary is to have procurement expertise on behalf of the customer or to
provide financing to fulfill the end customer’s purchase requirement. In both cases
full disclosure of costs and profits is required. Profit is set for both the goods and the

term. Thus, the profit made by the seller is proportional to the risk of non-payment by
the customer. Murabaha claims its requirements as a fixed agreement for the sale of
value-added and mark-up goods. In this case, the seller owns the asset before the sale
and decides to sell it at the desired value, sets the price with a markup added for the
customer. In other words, if the purchase price is 100,000 notional units and the
financial institution has agreed to a mark-up of 20% to finance the purchase for three
months, the sale price will be 120,000 notional units. This type of contract involves
an intermediary in the form of a financial institution, which is necessary because of
the end buyer’s lack of experience or the client’s need for credit. Murabaha is also
common due to the fact that in this method, the financing price is disclosed as an
addition to the purchase price at the time the seller extends trade credit to the
customer. In murabaha financing, the Islamic financial institution assumes the role of
an intermediary, purchasing the required goods on the customer’s order and then
selling them at cost with a markup. The customer is provided with information about
the rate of profit, payment schedule and term of financing (Musallamova, 2019).

The basic terms and conditions of financing under the murabaha contract,
consistent with the principles and requirements of Islamic economics, are as follows:

(I) The purchase price reflecting the amount of financing should be disclosed to
the customer;

II) The cost of financing should not be calculated in the form of interest with the
outstanding amount of financing;

(III) Transparency of facilities in terms of appearance, maintenance and cost and
profit accounting is encouraged;

IV) The customer, as a buyer has the right to approach the seller for any
anomalies (deviations from the benchmark) of the product or can cancel the contract;

V) It is permissible to charge the customer an advance payment or deposit as a
form of purchase commitment.

When financing a murabaha contract, assets may be taken as collateral to
provide security for the Islamic financial institution to recover the financing amount.
In case of delay or inability to pay by the customer, the financial institution should
provide convenient repayment terms. However, any form of default or delinquent
behavior on the part of the solvent debtor shall result in termination of this contract or
the right to pay the prescribed penalty. Payment of the penalty shall be treated as a
charity and not as income to the financial institution. Any discount received by the
FII seller, such as a trade discount, must benefit the customer and work in the
customer’s favor.

When providing financing to a customer by buying and selling an asset, the FMI
is not permitted to repurchase the asset back or vice versa. This situation arises when

a customer owns an asset and seeks to refinance by selling it and then repurchasing it
from the seller. Alongside this, some FFIs provide funding to a client by selling its
assets and buying the asset back from the client. In both cases, there is no actual sale,
as the economic benefit of the asset remains with the seller (Oziyev, 2015).

There are three steps involved in murabaha financing. First, the goods to be
purchased by the client are identified. Second, the FII buys the goods for cash after
receiving a purchase order from the client. Finally, the goods are sold to the customer
in installments (in most cases), followed by cash, immediately on the basis of one of
the payments (based on the purchase order). These steps require precision in the
recognition and measurement of assets. At the time of purchase of a non-cash asset,
the FFI records the asset on the balance sheet at the purchased value and reports it.
Any unfavorable and favorable price movement in the valuation of the asset is
recorded on the FFI’s balance sheet before the asset is sold to the customer. One such
case is a change in the value of inventory in an FFI asset matter. In most cases, the
financial institution protects its risk by purchasing the asset and immediately
transferring it to the customer with a repurchase obligation. This reduces the impact
of the risk and the value is retained at book value. For example, equipment is
purchased by an FMI for 50,000 conditional unit. If the value of the equipment
depreciates by 10% due to a delay in delivery, the equipment is valued at 45,000. The
loss of 5,000 is covered by the FII. On the other hand, if the equipment is delivered to
the customer immediately, the impact of this depreciation can be avoided.

When financing the murabaha, the financial institution adopted different
approaches to its accounting. For example, a profit margin of 20% was set to the
selling price of the equipment. The selling price - 50,000 + 10,000 = 60,000.
Reporting the amount of financing differs in practice. For example, if both financial
institutions A and B accept 50,000 as the actual financing amount and 500 as
collateral for doubtful debt, financial institution B may also recognize 10,000 c.u.
(conditional unit) as the amount of deferred profit. Disclosure of the deferred gain
would be appropriate because it would allow the FFI to track the amount of the gain.
In the case of financial institution A, a memorandum entry is provided to support the
transaction. The financing amount for the transaction is recognized as 60,000,
including 10,000 of deferred gain and receivables collected from the customer at the
time of payment. Institution B’s statement will provide the net amount of murabaha
after subtracting the deferred profit and bad debt collateral.

Murabaha assets and murabaha financing income have always been a topic of
discussion in terms of recognition as sales or financing income. The profit of a
financial institution is recognized as trading profit when a murabaha asset whose
goods are credited to the balance sheet of the financial institution as inventory is then

sold to a customer at a profit. However, if the financing is at a certain rate, which is
considered a very important aspect for determining income, then the income in this
case is recognized as financing income. As mentioned above, murabaha income is
recognized from the deferred murabaha profit specified in the contract. The total
amount of murabaha income recognized should not exceed the amount of deferred
profits. This is the peculiarity of the murabaha in which the amount of profit is
considered to be capped, that is, the initial recognized profit does not usually change
(Hazzar, 2018). Any income recognized beyond this limit will be prohibited as it may
amount to interest or usury. Therefore, the FII should focus on paying on time for
each period and collecting for unpaid financing. According to the method of
calculation, profits are calculated and recognized over a fixed period. Any extension
of the murabaha financing period means that there is no accrued profit in the
extended period because the total profit does not exceed the agreed costs and rate
overruns.

IFIs apply various methods of recognizing revenue and profit from Murabaha.
The most common methods are gross proportionate and constant rate of return
recognition methods.

These two methods are presented below:
Gross Proportional Method:
The acquisition cost is 100,000 c.u. The murabaha financing for the customer is
for five years at an annual rate of 10%. Therefore, the profit will be 10% x 100,000 x
5 = 50,000 c.u. The annual payment is 30,000 c.u. The murabaha receivable is
150,000 c.u. Thus, income is recognized at 1/3 of each payment. Out of the 30,000
c.u. received, 10,000 c.u. is recognized as income. Delinquency of payment beyond
the time limit set by the financial institution, e.g. three months, is not recognized for
the amount financed and revenue recognition is suspended.

Table 2

5 - year payment schedule

Years Payment Income (10 %) Decrease in principal Residual
amount amount
1 30000 10000 100000
10000 20000 80000
2 30000 10000 20000 60000
10000 20000 40000
3 30000 10000 20000 20000
20000 0
4 30000

5 30000

In the rate-of-return method of profit recognition, the financing amount is
assumed to be 100,000 c.u. The murabaha financing for the customer is set for five
years with a rate of return of 10% per annum. An annuity payment schedule based on
compound interest rates is developed. For a five-year annuity with an annualized rate
of 10%, the annual payment is 26,379 c.u. based on an annuity schedule. The
murabaha funding amount is 131,895, and the gain realized on the income would be
(26,379 x 5) - 100,000 = 31,895. Thus, 10% of the financing amount received will be
recognized as income for the annual payment of 26,379. In the first year, income of
10,000 c.u. is recognized.

Table 3
5 - year payment schedule

Years Payment Income (10 %) Decrease in principal Residual
amount amount
1 26379 10000
2 26379 8362 16379 100000
3 26379 6561 18017 83621
4 26379 4579 19818 65604
5 26379 2393 21800 45786
23986 23986

0

In cases of late payment beyond the time limit set by the financing authority,
e.g., three months, the amount financed is not considered valid and revenue
recognition is suspended. For most financial institutions, the second method is the
preferred method. The reason is that this method recognizes revenue at the rate of
10% of the unrecovered funding. However, in this format, it must be monitored to
ensure that the revenue calculation does not exceed the established markup. If the
customer fails to comply with the payment schedule and the delinquency exceeds a
set period of time, such as 90 days, the financing is considered defaulted in
accordance with the jurisdiction’s rules and the income earned is suspended. The
reason for this is that income cannot be accumulated indefinitely. In addition, Board
decisions may impose penalties on customers who may, but do not, fulfill payment
terms. The accrual of such a penalty is not like the accrual of interest. For example, if
a penalty at a fixed rate of 1% per annum is charged on the outstanding balance for a
specified period, this amount will be applied as compensation to the FII. In some
cases, the proceeds of such fines are intended to cover monitoring costs, but in most
cases they are distributed as charitable contributions.

CONCLUSION
Hence, murabaha income is recognized based on the method of accounting.
Deferred murabaha income is reduced as income is earned. Financing is considered

non-performing if the customer fails to comply with the payment schedule and the
delinquency exceeds the prescribed period.

Under the FII asset acquisition rule, assets must be measured at historical cost at
the time the contract is entered into. Once assets have been acquired with a
commitment to deliver to the customer, the assets must be measured at the same cost
as historical cost or net realizable value, whichever is lower. If they were acquired
without such a commitment, the assets should be measured at the equivalent cash
cost. In this case, additional disclosure is required to establish the value of the asset.
Any discount received at the inception of a contract, such as a commercial discount,
should not be recognized as revenue but should be treated as a reduction in the price
of the goods. The proposed rule would require that the discount be passed on to the
customer (discount revenue) and recognized in the accounting records.

Assets are transferred to the customer at a mark-up and the FMI recognizes the
deferred gain in the receivables structure. Deferred income is recognized as unpaid
receivables from the murabaha. The murabaha’s receivables should be recorded at
cash value, i.e., reduced to allowance for doubtful accounts. In murabaha financing,
when an asset is sold to a customer on credit, the markup on the asset is recognized as
a sign of profit. If the financing may involve multiple payments and the term of the
loan exceeds one accounting period, income will be regularly allocated to the
payment schedule in proportion to the accounting period(s). Under the accounting
method (i.e., revenue is recognized when goods are delivered to the customer or
services are rendered, rather than when money is received) is recognized on a pro rata
period basis, whether or not money is received from the customer. For uncollectible
receivables, an allowance for doubtful accounts should be provided. However, under
the cash basis, revenue and profit are recognized as payments are received, which
may be a requirement of the Supervisory Board or the regulator of a particular
jurisdiction. Financing costs, expenses and income are recognized on a matching
basis. On settlement, the invoice amount represents the outstanding financing
amount, including deferred income. The calculation relies on two methods. The first
method allows a portion of the gain to be deducted on settlement, while the second
method requires full recognition with the retention (refund) of a portion of the gain
upon settlement.

REFERENCES:
1. Archer S.R., Ahmed T. (2003) Emerging standards for Islamic financial
institutions: the case of the accounting and auditing organization for Islamic financial
institutions/ World Bank.
2. Archer S., Karin R., Al-Deehani T. (1998) Financial Contracting,
Governance Structures and the Accounting Regulation of Islamic Banks: an analysis

in terms of Agency Theory and Transaction Cost Economics // Journal of
management and Government. Vol. 2.

3. Cebeci İs. (2010) Modern Islam iktisadı literatüründe murabaha tartışmaları.
Doktora tezi. – İstanbul: Marmara üniversitesi.

4. Грицишен, Д.А. (2011) Регулирование бухгалтерского учета в
мусульманских странах: общая Характеристика // Международный
бухгалтерский учет. №15. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/regulirovaniebuhgalterskogo-ucheta-v-musulmanskih-stranah-obschaya-harakteristika

5. Назаренко, М. А. (2016) Оценка в бухгалтерском учете. Признание
объектов в соответствии с РПБУ и МСФО // Лучшая студенческая статья. –
C. 87-93.

6. Курноскина, О. Г. (2006) Сделки с недвижимостью. – Москва:
Юстицинформ.

7. Клеблеева, Р. Ш. (2014) Исламская модель бухгалтерского учета:
предпосылки возникновения и история развития // Проблемы современной
экономики. – №. 1 (49). – С. 272-278.

8. Kudryashov, V.V. (2015) Institutionalization of Islamic finance: the
international and legal aspects // Islam in the Modern World, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 53–
64. URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.20536/2074-1529-2015-11-2-53-64

9. Мусаллямова, М. Ф. и др. (2019) Особенности бухгалтерского учета и
оценки специфических исламских финансовых инструментов.

10. Озиев, Г. (2015) Контрактная основа исламского банкинга. – Москва:
Исламская кн. – 110 с.

11. Куликова, Л.И. (2016) Показатели оценки деловой активности
компании // Успехи современной науки. – Т. 2. – № 2. – С. 57–63.

12. Султанбекова, Д. Н. (2017) Особенности исламской модели
бухгалтерского учета.

13. Токарева, Е. В. (2015) Методика учета операций финансовой аренды у
арендодателя в соответствии с МСФО (IAS) // Известия Нижневолжского
агроуниверситетского комплекса: Наука и высшее профессиональное
образование, (3 (39)), 255-260.

14. Хаззар М. Э., Михеева И. Е., Алексеева Д. Г. (2018) Правовые
особенности этического (исламского) банкинга (на примере договора мурабаха)
// Вестник Пермского университета. Юридические науки. – №. 39. – С. 134-145.

15. Шариатские стандарты / Организация бухгалтерского учета и аудита
исламских финансовых учреждений. – Москва: Издательство «Исламская
книга», 2017. – 920 с.